Skip to main content

Cornell University

Faculty Advancing Inclusive Mentoring

A Collaboration of the Graduate School, Provost's Office of Faculty Development & Diversity, and TRUST Alliance

Practical Toolkit

This toolkit includes practical tools and resources to support mentor and mentee pairs as they collaboratively establish, communicate, and refine mutual expectations within their mentoring relationships.

Mentorship Plan Development

Tool to identify predispositions towards mentoring.

The FAIM Mentor/Mentee Mentorship Expectations Scales Worksheet is a practical tool meant to help mentors and mentees to identify their initial beliefs about responsibilities within their mentoring relationship and to identify where beliefs converge and diverge.

Download Here

Purpose

This resource should be used at the initiation of a mentoring relationship to allow the mentor and mentee to self-reflect on how each of them understands mentorship and to identify where the mentor's and mentee's beliefs converge and diverge. 

Instructions

Step 1

The mentor and mentee should independently review and respond to the FAIM Mentor / Mentee Mentorship Expectations Scales worksheet. 

Step 2

A mentor and a mentee should then collaboratively review their responses within the FAIM Mentor / Mentee Mentorship Expectations Scales worksheet, ask questions, and make clarifications. This will allow mentors and mentees to more easily identify where their ideas converge and diverge as they collaboratively establish mutual expectations.

As a next step, a mentor and mentee should meet to discuss and begin drafting their Mutual Expectations Agreement Plan, which will serve as their mentoring plan. During this initial discussion, the mentor and mentee should begin to communicate about their mutual expectations for their mentoring relationship.

Tool to establish, communicate, and refine shared expectations within a one to one mentoring relationships.

The FAIM Mutual Expectations Agreement Plan is a practical tool meant to support a faculty mentor and graduate student mentee as they set, communicate, refine, and manage their mutual expectations. Items include: communication, feedback, professional development, and more.

Download Here

Purpose

Mentors and mentees should individually reflect and collaboratively discuss, set, communicate, and refine their mutual expectations.

Instructions

We recommend mentors and mentees engage with the FAIM Mentor / Mentee Mentorship Expectations Scales worksheet prior to discussing and filling out the FAIM Mutual Expectations Agreement Plan. The Scales worksheet can help mentors and mentees identify where their ideas about mentorship may converge and diverge.

We also recommend mentors and mentees use the FAIM Identifying and Defining Your Values worksheet to identify and explore how to live your core values through decision-making and behaviors in academic and professional relational environments.

Step 1

The mentor and mentee meet and use draft responses and the FAIM Core Mutual Expectations for Graduate Education to inform the collaborative development of their personalized FAIM Mutual Expectations Agreement Plan. 

Step 2

The mentor and mentee review, discuss, and finalize their individualized FAIM Mutual Expectations Agreement Plan. The plan should reflect a mentor’s and mentee’s collective understanding of mutual expectations and commitments to one another and serve as a guide for the ongoing management of their mentoring relationship.

Step 3

The mentor and mentee should revisit the FAIM Mutual Expectations Agreement Plan on a cyclical basis to make changes reflective of where the mentee is in their degree progression and the current needs of the mentoring relationship.

Tool to support introspection in areas critical to approaches to mentoring relationships.

The FAIM Worksheet to Identify and Define Your Values is a practical tool meant to help mentors and mentees to identify and define their core values and consider how they are applied within their mentoring relationships.

Download Here

Purpose

This worksheet can help you identify your core values, or the ways of thinking and being that you hold most important. It can also help you explore how to practice living your core values through decision-making and actions in academic and professional relational environments, such as within a research team or a one-to-one mentor/mentee relationship.

Instructions

Step 1

Review the comprehensive, but not exhaustive, list of values in this resource.

Step 2

Identify and circle up to 10 values that resonate most with you.

Step 3

Reflect upon the 10 core values you identified and select the 5 values most important to you. Next, select the 2 core values that are essential to who you are and underlie your actions.

Step 4

After you identify your 2 core values, complete this worksheet to capture:

  • How do you already, or aspire, to demonstrate your core values within your professional and academic relationships?
  • What tendencies do you have that may be misaligned with your values?
  • What circumstance might make it difficult to act in accordance to your values (e.g., times of stress, conflict, etc.)?
Step 5

Identify a few tactics to realign your decisions with your core values.

Mentor Network Map

A Mentor Network Map is a practical tool to help identify existing mentors within your network and the roles they play as well as your unmet mentoring needs. For areas of unmet need, a map can inform your plan of how and with whom to expand your existing network.

Download Here

mentor network map for graduate students to map and strengthen their mentoring network can be found as a downloadable worksheet in the FAIM Practical Tools and Resources folder. For more information and resources on how to complete a mentor network map, visit the NCFDD Mentor Network Map resource page.

  •  

Individual Development Plans

Individual Development Plans are practical tools to identify academic and career goals and actions to make progress toward the realization of these goals.

Science Careers Individual Development Plan helps employees define and pursue their career goals. myIDP provides:

  • exercises to help you examine your skills, interests, and values.
  • a list of 20 scientific career paths with a prediction of which ones best fit your skills and interests.
  • a tool for setting strategic goals for the coming year, with optional reminders to keep you on track.
  • articles and resources to guide you through the process.
  •  

Imagine PhD is a free online career exploration and planning tool for PhD students and postdoctoral scholars in the humanities and social sciences. Imagine PhD provides tools for scholars to:

  • assess their career-related skills, interests, and values.
  • explore careers paths appropriate to their disciplines.
  • create self-defined goals.
  • map out next steps for career and professional development success.
  •  

Research Group Shared Expectations

The the FAIM Guide to Establish Research Group Expectations is a practical tool meant to support faculty mentors and research groups as they set, communicate, and refine their shared group expectations.

Download Here

Purpose

The FAIM Guide to Establish Research Group Shared Expectations is a practical tool for research group discussions in the following areas:

  • communicating and clarifying the mission of the research group;
  • defining shared values for scholarly engagement within the group;
  • sustaining and refining shared values;
  • establishing community norms and standards; and
  • creating and maintaining supportive and productive research environments.

Mentors and mentees can use this tool to individually reflect and then collaboratively discuss, set, communicate, and refine their shared group expectations.

Step 1

All group members should review the prompts in this resource as well as the FAIM Identifying and Defining Your Values worksheet independently ahead of a group meeting to prime themselves for a productive discussion.

The FAIM Identifying and Defining Your Values worksheet can help you identify and explore how to live your core values through decision-making and behaviors in academic and professional relational environments.

Step 2

Schedule a research group meeting dedicated to creating shared expectations agreements.

Step 3

During a meeting, the research group should discuss each item, and individual group members should share their thoughts. The faculty mentor should help make sure every group member has an opportunity to share their reflections and ideas before, during, and/or after the group meeting.

Step 4

Codify the group’s collective shared expectations agreements.

Step 5

Cyclically engage in discussions to refine the research group shared expectations, especially during times of transition (e.g., project completion, changes to the group’s composition).

Notes
Research Group Guidebooks, Manuals, etc.

Developing a shared expectations agreements is distinct from a group guidebook. The former requires dialogue and co-construction within the entire group, whereas the latter is prescribed by the head of the research team, or faculty mentors. A sample handbook can be found here.

FAIM Practical Tools & Resources

Access and download all of the current tools and resources within the FAIM Practical Toolkit for Mentoring in Graduate Education available to support the development of inclusive and supportive mentoring relationships.

External Practical Tools and Resources

NCFDD

The NCFDD is a national organization that supports faculty development. NCFDD provides a core curriculum to teach you the 10 key skills necessary to thrive in the Academy. NCFDD defines “thriving” as having extraordinary writing and research productivity AND having a full and healthy life off campus.

Equity in Graduate Education Resource Center

The Equity in Graduate Education Resource Center advances equity in graduate education by conducting and translating research that is inspired by community needs, and offering high-quality, evidence-based professional development that provides faculty and administrators with tools and resources to create and sustain institutional change.

Resources provided by the EGE Resource Center include a toolkit designed to engage mentors in deeper thinking about how mentoring relationships in graduate education can embody equity-mindedness. The exercises in the Equity-minded mentoring toolkit are designed to help establish shared understandings of mentoring expectations and facilitate conversations about equity in mentoring relationships.

NASEM The Science of Effective Mentoring in STEMM

National Academy of Science, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) interactive online guide to the Science of Effective Mentoring in Science, Technology, Engineering, Math, and Medicine (STEMM) provides guidance and tools to help develop and maintain strong and effective mentorship..

Council of Graduate Schools

The CGS Great Mentoring in Graduate School: A QUICK START GUIDE FOR PROTÉGÉS is a resource to help graduate students identify quality mentors and serve as helpful peer mentors to others.